by Jillian Kaplan
Photo by Andrey Zaychuk on Unsplash
In the vast realm of literature, characters come to life as master storytellers, conflict architects, and mirrors that reflect the complex aspects of human nature. Amidst the diverse list of characters, villains and anti-heroes distinguish themselves as unique archetypes, each imparting distinctive nuances to the narratives they inhabit.
Although sharing similarities in nature and values, their roles in a story fulfill entirely different purposes. Villains serve as catalysts for conflict against the hero and generators of tension. They ensure a well-paced narrative with dynamic quality. In contrast, antiheroes often embody moral ambiguity, engaging in morally questionable actions for what they perceive as a just cause. Deviating from conventional heroism, they adhere to a set of values that guide their actions. It is within the realm of moral complexity that villains and anti-heroes diverge.
Villains are arguably one of the most important parts of storytelling. These characters are driven by selfish motives, a desire for power, or need to disrupt harmony within the narrative. While the hero is a stepping stone to highlight what is just, it is the villain who motivates them. Their roles also highlight how these heroic qualities serve as a catalyst for the protagonist’s emotional development.
That is not to say that they are unredeemable. Nearly every form of storytelling has a villain, and sometimes the villain may even be the protagonist. In the art of storytelling, villains are deemed selfish and out for only themselves. In Harry Potter, it is Lord Voldemort; Hannibal Lecter in Silence of the Lambs; Count Dracula in Dracula; Scar in the Lion King.
Anti-heroes have a slightly different motivation. Like villains, they usually have a tragic background that made them the way they are. While villains and their motivations are purely selfish, anti-heroes and their motives are usually clouded by personal flaws or unconventional methods. They may stem from a desire to rectify perceived injustices or to challenge societal norms. In many instances, the anti-hero may very well be the protagonist. Some anti-heroes you might know include Scarlett O’Hara in Gone with The Wind, Jay Gatsby in The Great Gatsby, Macbeth in Macbeth, and many more.
Anti-heroes bring a moral complexity to a story that often plays with the reader’s emotions. It is difficult to dislike the anti-hero because at their core, they are usually good but misguided. In the way that villains are a character tool to highlight the moral qualities of the heroes, anti-heroes serve as a tool to deconstruct these heroic archetypes. They embrace the flaws of characters, imperfections, and their internal struggles. This unorthodox approach blurs the line between what a hero and a villain are and offers a redemption to comment on the morality of the characters.
Villains and anti-heroes emerge as crucial threads in the enormous tapestry of storytelling, weaving narratives of conflict, morality, and human nature. While villains represent the darkness that opposes the forces of good, anti-heroes negotiate the gray areas, offering readers with characters whose moral ambiguity encourages reflection and interaction. Villains and anti-heroes are literary devices used to emphasize the psychological aspects of characters and their decisions. The depth of their struggles, resistance to conventionality, and moral ambiguity make them difficult to label as “good” or “bad.”
The distinction between villains and anti-heroes is found not only in their deeds, but also in the motivations, moral landscapes, and transformative journeys that define their narratives and leave lasting effects on the stories they inhabit.
Jillian Kaplan is a literary enthusiast double majoring with Editing, Writing, and Media and Media Communication Studies. She was an editorial assistant for the fiction section. Her interests include reading, movies/tv shows, music, cooking, writing, and more!
The Kudzu Review 
Leave a comment